"After being taken first overall by the NY Islanders in the 2025 NHL Draft, a lot rests on the shoulders of Matthew Schaefer. Turning 18 years old less than three weeks ago, the young defenseman has shown maturity off the ice at an unprecedented level. But on the ice, playing in the NHL is a step up from anything he's seen before. Making his preseason debut on Sunday, Schaefer showed moments where some rust had to be shaken off, but overall, his performance was wildly impressive."
"The question was raised after Sunday's game when Cam Robinson, Content Director and Director of Film Scouting for Elite Prospects, posted on X that he received a message from a team-side source, stating: "Watching Matthew Schaefer's preseason debut. He might be a top pair guy right out of the box." While the Islanders have high hopes for the league's top prospect, the reins should be pulled in a bit."
Matthew Schaefer, the first overall pick by the New York Islanders in the 2025 NHL Draft, is 18 and has demonstrated notable off-ice maturity. He made his preseason debut and displayed elite skating, offensive willingness, and moments of rust that are typical for a player adjusting to the NHL level. A team source suggested he could be a top-pair defenseman immediately, but the Islanders will likely give him a nine-game trial before deciding whether he stays or returns to the Erie Otters in the OHL. Historical trends show young defensemen usually need more development, with few rookies winning the Calder Trophy.
Read at Eyes On Isles
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]